January 06, 2005

Ab-Normal Beauty Review

abnormal.jpgChock full of gorgeous – and disturbing – cinematography Oxide Pang’s Ab-Normal Beauty represents both the best and the worst of the Pang Brothers approach. Absolutely stunning to look at the film is a text book case of style over substance and ultimately proves to be a fairly shallow, by-the-numbers shocker.

Jiney is a young art school student raised by a largely absent – both emotionally and physically – mother. Her art, particularly her photography, has won her the acclaim of both her peers and her professors but it leaves her feeling cold. She is unsatisfied with her own work and holds it largely in contempt until she happens upon a fatal car crash and, torn between revulsion and fascination, snaps a shot of a slain pedestrian. This morbid shot awakens some emotion within her and Jiney promptly proclaims this her ideal subject. She becomes increasingly obsessed with death, snapping shots of suicides and hiring butchers to slaughter animals on camera, until her fixation threatens to overwhelm her and she finally pulls away from the precipice. All seems well until someone anonymously leaves photographs and a video for her, photos and film that appear to be an actual killing staged and caught on camera specifically for her …

Gratuitous nudity, snuff films, an obsessive stalker or two, a lesbian love interest, childhood trauma … in his effort to shock the audience Oxide Pang stuffs a little bit of everything in here, but what he forgets is to give us a reason to care about the central character. In many ways the flaws in Ab-Normal Beauty mirror those of The Eye 2 – lots of eye candy but very little in the way of character.

The root of the problem lies with both the overly busy script, jumping from situation to situation without giving the characters any real time to breath, and with the cast. Despite somewhat slight scripts – a common problem for the Pangs – The Eye and Bangkok Dangerous both succeed incredibly well thanks to the subtle, textured performances of Angelica Lee and Pavarit Mongkolpisit respectively, but there is no comparable performance here. Rather than casting experienced actors up to the challenge of carrying the emotional load Pang has opted for a pair of completely inexperienced pop stars in the leads and though neither performance is particularly embarrassing both play things in the broadest possible strokes and ultimately strip the film of whatever emotional punch it may have had.

On the plus side the film is beautifully shot and edited. The Pang Brothers are a pair of the most technically accomplished film makers in the world and while that focus on technique can sometimes overwhelm their characters they simply shoot gorgeous film. There are breathtaking shots scattered throughout the film, the composition is flawless and the film is edited with punch and style. The only technical hiccup is the overly dramatic score which I suspect may have been punched up some in an effort to compensate for the rather emotionally flat performances. In terms of the film work Ab-Normal Beauty nestles up to The Eye 2 at the very top of the Pang Brothers pile but in over all impact it sits somewhere in the middle of the pack. I’ve not yet become as frustrated with The Pangs as I have with Japan’s Ryuhei Kitamura but they’d best come up with a decent script sometime soon if they don’t want to start bleeding away their global fan base …

» Posted by Todd at January 6, 2005 01:45 PM

Reader Comments

The difference between the Pangs and Ryuhei Kitamura is that Kitamura makes "entertainment" movies, and he knows it, while the Pangs make beautiful films that rarely have the stories to back up the visuals and yet try to make them seem deeper than they really are.

» Posted by crazybee at January 6, 2005 02:08 PM

I agree with you, there, bee ... I just picked on Kitamura because he's another highly visual director who has consistent script problems ...

I think the problem with the Pangs started after The Eye did so well and someone decided to turn them into a brand ... this three Pang films a year thing is crazy. There's just no way it leaves enough time to prep a decent script. The only people who succeed at that level of output - and really the only one I can think of is Miike right now - are people who shoot other people's scripts. As long as the Pangs keep cranking things out so fast while also writing their own stuff we're probably going to keep seeing spotty stuff from them ... I mean this and Leave Me Alone both just released and they've already got at least three other films in production. You just can't maintain that ...

» Posted by Todd at January 6, 2005 02:48 PM

For my money, THE EYE was a nice balance between style and substance, and really opened my eyes up (so to speak) to some non-US-imported asian directors back in 2002 when I caught it at the Toronto Film Festival.
The Tesseract was a large failure, but still had some strengths (mainly visual).

Kitamura has an editting problem, now I don't often complain about film lengths, but Alive and Versus could have each used a 30+ minute trim, it would have vastly improved things...

The Spinning cam in Versus around the two principle characters for like 5 minutes has now become a averb for us...(as in "The camera has gone all Versus").

KuRt.

» Posted by Kurt at January 6, 2005 04:30 PM

I loved every freaking millisecond of Versus, and I'm still torn between the original cut and the 11 minute longer Ultimate version. Versus is like a religion to me, and I worship at the temple of Kitamura. I hope he makes Versus 2 next, and doesn't strike up a deal to direct watered-down shit with the Weinsteins producing.

» Posted by crazybee at January 7, 2005 02:10 PM

I think he's already made that deal, actually ... word is he's coming to the US for his next film after Godzilla. Speaking of which, has anybody heard anything about a DVD release? The Hong Kong ought to be coming sometime soon ...

» Posted by Todd at January 7, 2005 02:15 PM

Of Godzilla Final Wars? I wouldn't imagine a Japanese DVD release anytime soon (it only came out a month ago), and I don't think it has even hit HK cinemas yet, if it ever will.

» Posted by crazybee at January 7, 2005 02:31 PM

I guess, stylish directors will always have problems with the narrative of the story (I can cite out a lot of italian horror directors right now). Ab-normal Beauty had a lot of good things going for it, unfortunately the Pang Brothers didn't care to find a very good scriptwriter to do that for them.

» Posted by Kathy Bjelland at March 10, 2005 09:06 AM

Post A comment

Remember Me?   

(You may use HTML tags for style)

Twitch Settings

Contact Twitch

Got something to get off your chest? Click here for contact details.

Twitch Forum

Tired of listening to us prattle on? Join the Twitch Forum and have your own say!

DVD Release Calendar

A continual work in progress, our hefty list of upcoming, interesting DVD releases from around the world. Click here to let us know about any upcoming releases.

Retailers We Like

Shop at our affiliated sites and support Twitch while feeding your pop-culture addiction.

In Associate with YesAsia.com

Search Now:  


Search by CD, DVD or Game:



Misc