Occassional Twitch contributor James Maruyama checks in once again with a review of Katsuhiro OTomo's Mushishi, a film most in these parts found underwhelming when it played locally at the Toronto International Film Festival. Sadly, James agrees.
Otomo Katsuhiro's "Akira" (88) was truly a landmark film in Japanese animation and helped to bring cyperpunk animation to the forefront of sci-fi cinema. Unfortunately Otomo's numerous other projects thereafter (World Apartment, Memories, Steamboy) haven't really been able to match nor capture the excitement and wonder of that film. Which brings us to Otomo's current film "Mushishi", a truly bizarre and confusing film and one that is likely to test a viewer's patience.
"Mushishi" is based on Urushibara Yuki's long running manga of the same name published by Kodansha starting in 1999. It told the story of a young, white-haired shaman/mystic by the name of Ginko who has the unique ability to see ghostly and supernatural insects ("mushi") who would inhabit and afflict their human hosts with a number of mysterious ailments and sicknesses (some bordering on the grotesque). Using his supernatural abilities along with his medical/mystical knowledge, Ginko would travel feudal Japan to cure and treat those afflicted by the strange "Mushi".
It's one part the "Ghost Whisperer" mixed in with Tezuka Osamu's classic medical thriller "Black Jack".
The movie is visually very stunning with beautiful locations showcasing the colorful, lush and rustic Japanese countryside. The CGI effects for "Mushi" in particular are convincingly creepy and unnerving. The medical ailments range from the uninteresting (ear infections) to the painful (skin infections, protrusions) to the very bizarre (irratic behavior, tissue degeneration).
Yet as with his anime projects like "Memories" and "Steamboy" Otomo seems to get too caught up in the visual styling that the storytelling suffers from it. The story is told in a deliberately slow and methodical pace that may try the patience of modern audiences and the MTV crowd already accustomed to more frantic and faster pacing.
I'm not familiar with the source material, so it was very hard at times to follow the crux of the story. We never are told where these "mushi" come from and/or why they they do what they do which was a bit frustrating.
At two hours, the movie is overly long and I often found myself struggling to keep awake, hoping for some sort of exciting and climactic event that will hopefully shed light on all of these proceedings. That unfortunately never materialized.
Odagiri Joe doesn't really do much in his portrayal of Ginko rather playing the character as a atypical, stoic, silent hero who deals with the fantastical events he encounters with a disengaged almost bored manner.
Manga/comic adaptations are becoming all the rage now with "Death Note", "Dororo", "Nana" and the recent "Ge Ge Ge No Kitaro" having had much success on the big screen. "Mushishi" may be a case-in-point to producers that not all manga were meant to be adapted and that perhaps some stories are better kept to the confines of print publication or anime.
Review by James Maruyama
Thanks for the review James. I'd read the first three collected editions of the manga before watching the film so had no problems following what was going on, and was even impressed at how the screenwriter had put together a feature-length narrative from mostly episodic source material. I agree though that it could have benefited by being more concise, but then again that's an argument that could be used against a lot of contemporary Japanese features. To be fair to Odagiri, he was a perfect choice for the role and embodied Ginko well, but as the manga generally treats the character as more of a peripheral figure through which to tell the stories of the mushi-afflicted rather than as a genuine protagonist, the film's attempt to turn him into one was obviously not entirely successful. Still, as Otomo's second foray into live action I didn't think it was any worse than "World Apartment Horror" (I liked it), and at the very least it wasn't as big a let-down as "Steamboy". I'm sure quite a few out there will disagree though.
Well, personally, I loved both Memories and Steamboy, the latter of which seemed like an extension of the theme displayed in his Memories third.
Shop at our affiliated sites and support Twitch while feeding your pop-culture addiction.
|