July 11, 2007

Fantasia Report: Time Review

(Posted In Asia Drama Fantasia Festival 2007 Reviews Toronto Film Festival 2006 )

timestill.jpg[Fantasia info page here.]

It's back to the bad old days for director Kim Ki-Duk. After a string of much loved films that broke with the harsh, ranting polemics of his older work in favor of gentler meditations on life and love Kim is back to his old tricks with Time - available on DVD here - a film that shows he hasn't lost his angry edge and sets the stage for repeated accusations that the man is, essentially, a misanthrope who sees little in the world and people around him that doesn't inspire contempt. This is Kim in his Von Trier mode, brash and as subtle as a hammer blow to the head.

Time is the story of Seh-hee and Ji-woo, a young couple two years into their relationship. Though he never acts on his impulses Ji-woo has something of a roving eye and Seh-hee is intensely jealous and fearful that Ji-woo will soon lose interest and leave her. Believing that Ji-woo is bored with seeing the same, boring her all the time Seh-hee takes drastic action, leaving him without warning and having drastic cosmetic surgery, taking on a new face, which she hopes to use to snare him again, under an assumed identity, once she has healed. But when Ji-woo shows interest in this new and "improved" Seh-hee it triggers only more self doubt and loathing. After all, he may love the 'new' girl, but does this mean that he has rejected the old? Seh-hee is utterly trapped in her own insecurities, a situation that prompts Ji-woo to take drastic action of his own.

Time is a furious salvo launched at the cosmetic and image marketing industries, a vicious attack both on the women who take these artificial conepts of beauty seriously and at the companies who exploit them. Kim is absolutely livid at the lengths people will go to to attain beauty and, even moreso, at the twisting and corruption of the human spirit that results. "She must really love you," someone comments to Ji-woo after one of Seh-hee's out of control jealous outbursts, a statement delivered so glibly that it slides by almost without notice but this is surely one of Kim's key points: if that's love, who in their right mind would want it? If loving yourself or someone else involves these extremes then love must surely be one of the most destructive forces on the planet. This isn't love at all, Kim is arguing, but a sick obsession that is gnawing away and destroying people.

While you can't help but admire the sheer force of Kim's convictions here Time is marred by the same basic issue that plagues most of the films in the first half of Kim's career, namely that all of the principal characters are such horrible people that they are distasteful to watch. The beauty and grace of 3 Iron and Spring, Summer ... is entirely absent here, this is all vitriol and self loathing played out on the broadest possible scale with no subtlety whatsoever. Seh-hee and Ji-woo are less believable characters than they are basic types for Kim to pack all of his anger into. As a result while Kim's point is certainly heard the film makes for difficult viewing as you simply want these people to go away and Kim to stop yelling at you when a civil conversation or legitimately tragic story would get the job done just as well as this angry rant.

» Posted by Todd at July 11, 2007 12:53 PM
Digg This / Add To del.icio.us

Reader Comments

sounds wickeds

» Posted by zeus at September 17, 2006 01:58 PM

Maybe it's because I'm too cynical but I prefer Kim's 'angry' films. The characters may be distasteful and horrible but they are always punished for it. I love the scene when the lead actress approaches the two women in the cafe because her boyfriend looks at them, she's absolutely ferocious. I haven't seen Teshigahara's A Face of Another but I heard it's similar to this. Is Kim biting? I know he has been accused of it in the past.

» Posted by jai-l at July 11, 2007 09:42 PM

This is distressing to read. Not a big fan of Ki-Duk's older stuff, but Iron and Spring/Summer are two of my favorite films of all time.

Even though you kind of rip this, I'm ginna give it a shot. The premise sounds interesting enough to warrant a look-see.

Is the film as aesthetically pleasing as the films I mentioned above?

» Posted by Drewbacca at July 12, 2007 12:47 PM

Drewbacca, watch this movie, it's on par with 3 iron and spring summer

» Posted by shichibukai at July 14, 2007 03:08 AM

This is this one amazing scene, wherein the frolicking young lovers are likened to fluttering birds, and a few others I won't ruin for you, but for the most part it's long way from his best work (my favourites being Real Fiction and Spring, Summer, Autumn, Winter) – enough for me to no longer include him on my shortest lists of favourite artists, and to not be anywhere as excited about this year's Breath (Soom).

And is it just me, or was anyone else reminded of the Kate Bush song "Babooshka"? I was sure that the monochrome photo-mask confirmed this, as it so resembled those used in the video for "Running Up That Hill".

» Posted by Jordan S. at July 14, 2007 06:13 AM

Post Your Comments

Remember Me?   

(You may use HTML tags for style.)

  

Buy DVDs At The Twitch Store

Stuff We Like

Shop at our affiliated sites and support Twitch while feeding your pop-culture addiction.

Find your favorites


eThaiCD