March 21, 2006

Thoughts on Jet Li's Fearless

(Posted In Asia DVD News Martial Arts Reviews )

Fearless_brown.jpgAfter much anticipation the recently released Hong Kong DVD of Fearless - the film Jet Li claims will be his final wushu picture - has passed into my greedy hands. I hesitate to call what follows here a 'review' per se, since I have non of the needed language skills and the DVD does not include English subtitles. Yes, I ran a review of Tom Yum Goong in similar circumstances but this film - unlike that one - actually features a plot and some performances that go beyond the butt whuppin'. So what you're getting is by no means a complete review, but a collection of my impressions of the film.

First question: can Ronnie Yu and Jet Li still bring it old school style? Oh, yes. Yes, they can. The film is beautifully shot and with the exception of the improved effects could very easily have been a product of Hong Kong's golden age. It's been a while since Hong Kong made a film like this - overtly political, nostalgic, set in colonial times, etc - and this is a good one. I don't believe that it cracks Li's top tier of films and it will be a very hard sell to mainstream US audiences - more on that in a bit - but it is very, very good.

First, the quibbles, and there are a few.

Jet is getting old. At forty three he's not over the hill yet but he is beginning to show his age and this impacts things in a few areas. I have never enjoyed Li in 'goofy young master mode' and that is intensely the case here. When it comes to physical comedy Li is no Stephen Chow, and never has been, but he just looks silly when playing the young version of Huo Yuan Jia for laughs in the early going. Not only is he obviously far older than the character he is playing at this point but his version of youth consists too much of stumbling about and mugging for the camera. Thankfully this phase is over quickly and Li's undeniable screen presence begins to shine through once he is allowed to tap into the impatience, anger, and tragedy of the character.

More important to the martial arts fans out there, Li is visibly beginning to slow down. He is nowhere close to being over the hill yet but he has definitely crested the peak. The fights are still spectacular but if you were to compare this film side by side with Fist of Legend - an interesting project considering the interlocked characters and Yuen Wu Ping's work on both as fight choreographer - and it is clear that Li is no longer capable of things that once seemed to come effortlessly. Again, he is still one of the very best in the world but the decline, though slight, is apparent enough to make you wonder how much it played in to his decision to step back from wushu film.

On a related note, there is a surprising amount of technical trickery in the fight scenes, both in terms of wire work and altered film speeds, to goose things up a bit. While not nearly as intrusive as it is in many films the wires feel strangely out of place in a film that purports to be a straight ahead bio-pic. Again, compare to the 'set up the cameras and let 'em fight' approach of Fist of Legend.

And finally - the good stuff is coming - there is the comment made earlier about western prospects. Fearless is one of those films clearly made for a primary audience very well versed in the source material. Huo Yuan Jia is a legendary figure in China, one the film maker's can be certain their entire primary audience will be well familiar with and that allows them to take certain shortcuts and press certain buttons that simply will not resonate the same way with less knowledgable audiences. The political situation around the master's death seems largely taken for granted, the mid section of the film plays like a Coles Notes primer on his life more than an in depth drama, and it is very unlikely that audiences outside of China will appreciate the emotional crescendo of his death in nearly the same way that the Chinese would.

And now the good stuff.

Ronnie Yu is back. The Hong Kong A-lister dropped way down into the B - arguably even C - ranks when he made the move to Hollywood. It's been a long time since he had a high end film to work on and he hasn't lost a step. His camera is nimble, the staging is excellent, and it's just fantastic to see the man behind The Bride With White Hair back doing what he does best. Yes, he kept Freddy Vs. Jason from sucking as bad as it could have but is that enough to make up for his prolonged absence from martial arts films? Not by a long shot.

Production values are excellent with full marks going to a stellar design team. The environments are richly realized and recapture the colonial feel of so many great Hong Kong classics. Is it a bad thing to be so happy to see a big ol' pair of mutton chops on a boorish Brit? I think not.

Li himself. I have said many times that I do not believe Li gets the credit he deserves as an actor and I stand by that statement again here. Yes, he has his limitations - see the above 'young master' comments - but the man has an undeniable screen presence and the ability to convey volumes while doing very little. Playing Huo Yuan Jia gives Li very large shoes to fill and he does an admirable job on the dramatic front.

And, finally, the fights themselves. Has the combination of Jet Li and Yuen Wu Ping ever failed to impress? Nope. And while their work here may not rise quite to the heights of their work together in Fist of Legend there are many - myself among them - who consider that film one of the absolute untouchables of martial arts film. Their work in Fearless is inventive, engaging and breath taking. Li faces up with a wide array of opponents, each with a unique fight style, and aquits himself very, very well. The Nathan Jones fight offered less than I would have hoped but the sequences against a sword weilding Chinese master, British spear man and the final battle against a Japanese samurai are all top notch.

If Li holds true to his word and calls it a day on the wushu front with this one then, sad as it will be to see him go, he will at least be going out on a high note and on his own terms. I stop short of calling it a classic but it is very good.

» Posted by Todd at March 21, 2006 09:46 PM
Digg This / Add To del.icio.us

Reader Comments

Starting to feel like the review of our movie's been officially scrapped...

:(

» Posted by crazybee at March 21, 2006 11:09 PM

I thought the same exact thing about Li as the "young master". You could practically see the pain in his face as he grinned as wide as he could, non stop for the first 30 minutes or so. It hurt...

I'm not all that well versed in his life, but from what I read in a WikiPedia article on him (take that as you will), the film took a good deal of liberties with the events of his life - namely the death(s) early on. These were the emotional highs of the movie, so if they are a bit of a stretch then they do lose a little authenticity. Still a surprisingly inspiring film.

Nathan Jones' fight definitely was a let down from his work in Tom Yum Goong, but man just seeing him on screen makes me happy. I don't see why Fox didn't just cast him as Juggernaut and save a ton in effects.

» Posted by Peter at March 22, 2006 12:34 AM

Great Review. Loved the movie. Thanks!

» Posted by Andy at March 22, 2006 08:29 AM

Your review has some misunderstanding, probably due to language issue?? Jet was not playing a goofy young master. The first part was when he was younger but still in his 30s with a small daughter. I enjoy him playing that cocky fighter tremendously, much like he played the bad guy in LW4 and The One. And I agree that Jet Li does not get the credit he deserves as an actor and the undeniable screen presence and the ability to convey volumes.

» Posted by trigger at March 22, 2006 11:44 AM

Nope, I got that and I liked the cockiness and swagger of the younger phase it was when he went for goofiness with the little girl that I had some trouble. For all of his enormous skill I just don't think Jet does physical comedy well at all.

» Posted by Todd Brown at March 22, 2006 11:55 AM

You mean the little girl who played his daughter. Yes I hate that scene too the little girl wasn't even cute but it was only a two second scene. It really doesn't warrant such a bad review on his 'goofiness'. It wasn't meant to be any physical comedy. Comparing to FOL is also unfair, FOL was not well received in Asia and Jet had to close his production company after that because general audiences just did not like that kind of filming style. Moreover FOL was twelve years ago. I just hope you guy doesn't overplay his so-called retirement. I really don't want to see him go, he is best in period piece, and there are many Chinese historical hero he can play. I hate to see some non MA star pretending they can wield a sword, its so fake and they do not have the aura of a warrior. Remember Jackie Chan was still at career height when he was Jet's age.

» Posted by trigger at March 22, 2006 02:15 PM

How on earth do you figure comparing Fearless to Fist of Legend is unfair? Same star, same action director, and for all intents and purposes Fist of Legend is a continuation of this story. Same time period, same political situation, Jet's playing Huo's top disciple, and the events of Fist of Legend are triggered by the events at the end of Fearless. It's a fantastic point of comparison ... you really can't ask for better unless he goes out and makes another one directly about Huo himself.

And we're not the one's saying he's going to go, he's saying it himself and has done so repeatedly. Unless he has a major change of heart Fearless is his final wushu picture.

And when Jackie was Jet's age now he was making First Strike, Mr. Nice Guy, Who Am I and Rush Hour. Not exactly top flight stuff, though not truly horrible yet, either. Jackie's best stuff happened in 94 / 95 when he would have been three years younger (I believe) than Jet is now. It's been a steady decline in his skills since then and if Jet feels that he is cresting the wave and would rather pack it in than make his equivalent to The Tuxedo then I can't really blame him. I'd love to see Jet keep making a-list stuff but the body does slow down eventually ...

» Posted by Todd at March 22, 2006 02:45 PM

this movie rocked. would love to see the longer version someday but.

» Posted by louis at March 22, 2006 03:40 PM

I disagree with the comment about his acting comical in the beginning. From what I understand of the story and the character, he played that part like a father goofing off with his child like any parent would. When not with his daughter, he played his character outside of his family life as being overly competitive in an arrogant fashion. On my part, I felt he did a great job and has come a long way as being more than just a martial art/action star. He's proved he has a lot more than that. Jet Li's advantage over other guys like Jackie, Donnie, or a Wu Jing is that he's not only charismatic to watch on screen but he is a better actor. But, you are right that he isn't convincing as a youth. Perhaps when the subtitled version is released, people can get a better understanding that he wasn't trying to be comical.

» Posted by kenny wong at March 22, 2006 06:52 PM

I recently created a english subtitle file for this film using a couple of files floating around and some help from friends.

http://www.joshuapettigrew.com/Other/FearlessEngSubs32206.zip

Let me know if this file can be improved.

» Posted by Joshua Pettigrew at March 22, 2006 11:16 PM

Kennywong, good post!

There is still ten years in Jet before he made 'Tuxedo'. He only said he has talked everything about wushu (spirit side) in Fearless, so he has nothing more to say about the subject. I think the media has taken everything out of context.

» Posted by jetblack at March 23, 2006 12:14 PM

Fearless was absolutely one of the best movies ever made. The fighting scenes were just brilliant and Jet Li's acting was excellent whether he was playing a cocky character or not. I don't understand why you people are criticizing his acting. Tell me, what parent doesn't goof off with his or her toddler? It's a parent instinct and who said anything about him trying to be a comedian. No one said that he was trying to be the next Stephen Chow so there is absolutely nothing wrong with him being father like. Not to mention the little girl was cute and what is so wrong with acting goofy? Fearless sends out a moral to people and so does Jet Li through all his movies. Just because there's one or two scenes that people don't like doesn't mean that the whole movie is crap. It was a brilliant movie with great acting, morals and excellent stars so good on you Jet. I just want to know why you had to die. My mum and I had tears springing to our eyes!

» Posted by Jay So at April 8, 2006 03:45 AM

Fearless was absolutely one of the best movies ever made. The fighting scenes were just brilliant and Jet Li's acting was excellent whether he was playing a cocky character or not. I don't understand why you people are criticizing his acting. Tell me, what parent doesn't goof off with his or her toddler? It's a parent instinct and who said anything about him trying to be a comedian. No one said that he was trying to be the next Stephen Chow so there is absolutely nothing wrong with him being father like. Not to mention the little girl was cute and what is so wrong with acting goofy? Fearless sends out a moral to people and so does Jet Li through all his movies. Just because there's one or two scenes that people don't like doesn't mean that the whole movie is crap. It was a brilliant movie with great acting, morals and excellent stars so good on you Jet. I just want to know why you had to die. My mum and I had tears springing to our eyes!

» Posted by Jay So at April 8, 2006 03:46 AM

fearless was a really good film but we understand that he wanted to do it in his own language for his last film.
the fighting scenes was brilliant

» Posted by jock at July 13, 2006 11:00 AM

It's all subjective! Jet is still the best even now that he's older! Fist of Legend was undeniably great with real-time fight scenes, but the fight scenes in Fearless were also awesome.

» Posted by Geraldine at August 7, 2006 03:06 PM

Post Your Comments

Remember Me?   

(You may use HTML tags for style.)

  

Buy DVDs At The Twitch Store

Stuff We Like

Shop at our affiliated sites and support Twitch while feeding your pop-culture addiction.

Find your favorites


eThaiCD